Wednesday, September 9, 2020

Myers-Briggs Personality Tests Are Bullshit

 Myers-Briggs personality tests are bullshit.

Oh, the basic notion of trying to classify a personality by considering a variety of independent characteristics is sound enough. But the theory that inspired the test, that humans can be neatly divided into some scheme of Jungian archetypes constructed from opposing personality traits is just ... not true.

Take extroversion vs. introversion. This is a universally acknowledged personality trait (its one of the Big Five today). Any personality test or scheme for sorting people's personalities into boxes would have to include it. But there's just one problem: M-B assumes that personality traits have a bimodal distribution; that is, most people are in one bin or another, either extroverted or introverted.

Except that people don't work like that - extroversion is normally distributed. Most people aren't particularly extroverted or introverted. And that isn't some recent discovery. For example, below is a table from 1926(!) paper showing the distribution extroversion measured by means of a questionaire:

https://sci-hub.tw/https://doi.org/10.1037/h0074035

Note that the self-ratings are clearly normally distributed, while the peer-ratings appear to be slightly bimodally distributed. Given that the Briggs Myers Type Indicator Handbook was first published in 1944, how could psychologists, committed to empiricism and familiar with literature, endorse a schema that defied known facts?

The answer is that they didn't. Katherine Cook Briggs and her daughter Isabel Briggs Meyers were writers and enthusiastic students (I dare-say fangirls) of Jung who cooked up a theory to put Jungian psychology into practice and/or prove it correct. The goal wasn't to measure people's personalities as they actually existed but to sort people according to their "ideal type" so that they could try it on for size. This is because they believed that, per Jung's theorizing, people would be happiest and (more importantly) most productive if they behaved according to their "type".

You will notice that this resembles less the standard scientific research methodology than the process by which creationists disprove evolution by hunting for the Ropen.

If I was an ungenerous sort, I might describe this as haphazardly trying to stuff the rich diversity of human personality into 16 narrow boxes in order to make the world easier to understand. If I was extremely ungenerous I would draw your attention to the many was this sort of thinking is useful to reactionaries, if not intentionally  reactionary itself. There's probably a good essay to be written on that topic, but this dear reader, is not it.

But in any event, I am (or at least try to be) generous, and a more generous reading is that according to the theory of psychology that they believed, reacting to a test indicating that a person is slightly more extroverted than average and the M-B test goes and hands them a card saying "HOORAY!!!! YOU ARE AN EXTROVERT!!!! GO OUT AND BE SOCIAL!!! :)" is the correct therapeutic action. They really thought that if a person was of an "extroverted type" they would be happiest (and most productive) if they behaved in an extroverted way, and that giving them a label this really would help them, at least a bit, in a manner akin to how people with previously diagnosed psychological disorders might report that the mere fact of a diagnosis is helpful.

But the thing is, facts really don't care about your feelings, outcomes really don't care about your intentions, and that theory of how people's minds work and how to help them is, empirically wrong, and could easily have be proven wrong by anyone who cared to test it. The Meyers-Briggs personality test, its theoretical foundations, and all derived from it are essentially quackery (1).

Despite this, this construct and this test has wormed their way into all sorts of popular (and vital!) applications of psychometrics - human resources, career and academic advising, and online dating.

Why?

I think a clue is in that table from 1926. People's self-ratings of extroversion were normally distributed, but peer-ratings were bimodal. People want to sort other people into boxes, to analogize them to cultural constructs and archetypes. It makes the messy and complicated and chaotic social world easier to "understand" and to deal with. Its what makes the fundamental attribution error so fundamental. And the Meyers-Briggs test was designed and marketed towards directing students to careers where "their type" would be happiest and most productive and likewise directing workers to jobs where "their type" would be happiest and most productive. The application in online dating is essentially astrology for people who don't believe in astrology.

And all of that terrifies me. Because my happiness is very much dependent on the decisions of potential mates and potential employers, and they are making those decisions on the basis of quackery.

So I have written this, in the hopes that someone who previously gave it defunct theory weight will change their minds, and use something with an actual empirical foundation.


(1) Pace! Quackery isn't necessarily evil - I'm sure medieval doctors really did think that leeches would cure people's ailments, and under many theories of ethics acting with a desire to help is virtuous and good even your assistance actually makes things worse. And quackery isn't necessarily ineffective - there are a few diseases where applying leeches is a valid course of treatment. And of course even if the treatment itself doesn't actually do anything (like, I suspect, acupuncture) the placebo effect is so powerful a patient may be helped simply by virtue of being treated.

Wednesday, July 1, 2020

Data is not the new oil

"Data is the new oil" is a phrase that I fucking hate. It immediately causes me to question the knowledge, judgement, and ability of the speaker. I am suddenly overwhelmed with the suspicion that they are the sort of person who thinks Tom Friedman is a deep thinker with profound insights, the sort of management type who reads the Art of War and takes all the wrong lessons from it.

It is wrong, not only in whole, but in every particular part.

Permit me the polite fiction of asking your permission to explain.

What is data?

Per Wikipedia:
Data are characteristics or information, usually numerical, that are collected through observation.[1] In a more technical sense, data is a set of values of qualitative or quantitative variables about one or more persons or objects, while a datum (singular of data) is a single value of a single variable.[
Which is to say that data is not as old as writing - it is literally older. Since much of the proto-writing we have are bills of sale and ledgers and tax records. In the modern context that means (and I think this is clear from context) computerized data. And computerized data is very interesting, since computerized data is just any most any kind of information.

Because,while all data is non-exclusive (you knowing the tax records recorded on some Babylonian tablet doesn't preclude me from knowing it), computerized data is also essentially costless to duplicate.  It might be expensive to get, but once you  got it, its basically free to make copies. The same cannot be said for clay tablets.

But still, even the data on clay tablets is not some Vancian incantation, consumed upon use. We do not burn it to power our cars and planes, shape it into "temporary" containers that will outlive us all.

This means that data isn't just not scarce in the colloquial sense, but often also in the technical economic sense; i.e. everyone can have as much data as they want.

Not literally always, since data can still be expensive to gather, laborious to interpret and make use-able, and since secrecy and intellectual property laws create artificial scarcity. But consider pornography.

Pornographers cannot enjoy the protection of secrecy if they hope to make a profit, piracy is rampant (since making a copy is costless and the intellectual property rights of adult performers aren't generally taken seriously), people make amateur films for free (since the computer age has democratized information technology), and people have been making skin flicks for so long that people can get off to videos made before they were born (the stock does not diminish with time). All this translates into a world where the price of the data of pornography is pushed to zero and stays there. It is essentially the case that we, as a society, are post-scarcity in smut. And just as there can be no Saudi Arabia of porn, there can be no Saudi Arabia of data.

Whereas Saudi Arabia is the Saudi Arabia of oil.

What is oil? 

Oil is a kind of stuff. Specifically,  its hydrocarbons buried eons ago now dug up and refined into a fuel that can be burnt for energy. Exploiting (i.e. burning) the "fossilized" chemical energy of buried hydrocarbons like oil is essentially how the human race escaped the Malthusian trap of subsistence agriculture and entered the present era of sustained economic growth and industrialization.

And, not to put to fine a point on it, I think the Industrial Revolution was the single most important event in the history of the world. The Industrial Revolution (and by synecdoche, oil) transformed every feature of daily life in rich as well as poor countries - the keys on which I type this, the power that illuminates this screen, the very structure of the city and civilization in which I live - what oil has not made, it has at least put its dirty little fingers on.

But oil and other fossil fuels are not evenly distributed throughout the globe, and this has consequences. As mineral wealth it easy to control and exploit with violence so, it props up the otherwise weak economies of authoritarian states. Oil wealth can stifling economic growth in developing countries  impoverishing future generations.

And it is not just a valuable commodity but a military necessity. An army with tanks, trucks, and planes will overcome an army without these things in any (conventional) contest. Thus securing a steady supply has been one of the key objectives of American foreign policy. So much so that the idiot in the White House - who never met a subtext that he didn't make text - said that we were only in Syria for the oil

And finally, dreadfully, fossil fuels are the cause of the current climate catastrophe. To use the sterile language of economics, using oil has very large negative externalizes. Which is to say, to make, move, and use it not only harms the makers, movers, and users, but everyone around them - indeed, everyone in the whole world.

With all that, what would it mean for something to be the new oil?

It would have to be great and dreadful, to reshape the whole world in profound ways for good and ill. It would have to be scarce, and unevenly distributed, the sort of thing that a warlord could sell on international markets to finance their tyranny. It would have to be a military necessity, whose abundance or scarcity could make or break empires and war machines, something which even the most scrupulous and ethical of states (lolsob) would be compelled by necessity to buy from the most unscrupulous and unethical. It's use would have to harm the people around its users, and its possessors must, by the mere fact of possessing it, deny it to someone else.

Is data that?

No.

Why do people say it?

Its probably some manner of misbegotten metaphor. "Oil is important, data is important, therefore data is the new oil". Which, is wrong and misleading, and I hate it. Couldn't they be a little more poetic and say something like: "Ink is the new black gold"

Wednesday, June 24, 2020

Some Disordered Thoughts

So this is a thing that happened:
Image
https://wkow.com/2020/06/23/protesters-pull-down-forward-statue-outside-state-capitol/

Demonstrators had been marching around downtown Madison, frustrated after the arrest of a protester earlier in the day.

The same group also tore down the Col. Hans Christian Heg statue a short time later. The group then went on to throw the statue into Lake Monona. Heg fought for the Union during the Civil War and was a stark opponent of slavery during that time.

I have thoughts, and surprisingly feelings, on this that I would like to share.

Now I can image some preemption along the lines of  "Why are you talking about this when there's so much else going on?"

To which I respond:

A) Its my blog, I can write about what I want. Not everything has to serve some grand political purpose or be . This should go without saying, but so should a lot of things that still somehow need to be said.

Demonstrators had been marching around downtown Madison, frustrated after the arrest of a protester earlier in the day.
The same group also tore down the Col. Hans Christian Heg statue a short time later. The group then went on to throw the statue into Lake Monona. Heg fought for the Union during the Civil War and was a stark opponent of slavery during that time.
B) I don't think I have any message on police brutality, systematic racism, or many other parts of *gestures* all this that doesn't have a better messenger. But I am the worlds leading expert on my own feelings.

So, the story is that yesterday there was a protest in Madison, and after dark the folks who were left apparently decided on using vandalism as direct action. Fair enough, I suppose. And as part of this they tore down, decapitated, and dumped in the lake a statue of Col. Hans Christian Heg.

The TL;DR of Heg's life is that he was an immigrant and an abolitionist. He led Wisconsin's branch of the Wide Awakes. He commanded the 15th Wisconsin Volunteers and was, per the the inscription, felled at Chickamauga.

So naturally, in the context of national uprising against racism, police injustice, and that everything is fucked up and bullshit, protesters did this:

Image

And I think this was worse than a crime; it was a mistake. I could waste your time with a lot of dissembling along the lines of #notallprotestors, but bluntly I think that a lot of people are angry, some people just like to use the cover of protest to smash, and people do make mistakes like this when their blood is up.

Public monuments and statues are symbols. They make public statements about what, who, and how a community should commemorate the past. Given how much of politics is essentially aesthetic and symbolic (a fact which I am not terribly pleased with, but whose reality I acknowledge) erecting such statues is a symbolic and political act. So is tearing them down.

Building a statue of the traitor Lee in a black community in the 1960's says a combination of "Actually the Confederacy was good", "Fuck you" and "know your place".  Tearing down or vandalism that statue is a (long overdue) repudiation of all that.

Building statues is a symbolic act. Tearing them down is a symbolic act. But What is this supposed to symbolize? And more, meaningfully, what is actually symbolizing to people?

I won't pretend to know what the intention behind this was, but I suspect it wasn't terribly thought-out and the people responsible (assuming they are our noble comrades in the struggle for justice, and not fascist running-dogs trying to besmirch the good name of the Real Left) are either scrambling to construct a post-hoc rationalization, trying to quietly pretend it didn't happen, or blamimg someone else. That's what people usually do when the fuck up.

But in understanding how the the general public will interpret acts of anonymous vandalism like this there really is no other way to interpret the "text" than the death of the author.

And in that interpretation how would the general public interpret this? Chaos, destruction, disorder. I'm a bit worried that if this becomes what most people (who you need to remember are less political, less engaged, less informed than you - and will still be in November) associate with BLM, social justice, and left-of-center politics in general. Because, bluntly, there's a whole bunch of comfortable (white) people who don't have a preference between the peace of the conquered and the peace of justice as long there's peace. And if we want the peace of justice, we need to win in November, and win big, and that means getting at least some of those people to vote for us by showing them that its the police who are the rioters and the right that is party of  chaos, misrule and violence.

Thursday, February 27, 2020

Letter to the Editor 1

https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2020/02/26/across-country-rural-communities-secede-states-why-column/4851817002/


David Franks davidfranks31415@gmail.com

1:05 PM (2 minutes ago)
to letters
Reading his opinion, I could not decide whether Glenn was arguing in good faith and simply stupid, or whether he was arguing in bad faith and secretly yearned for tyranny.

Yes, tyranny. A strong word, but that seems to be the substance of the remedy he envisages. For all his hand-wringing talk of "tyranny of the majority" is to justify a system which would give more weight, power, and voice to a minority of the population, and thus institute a "tyranny of the minority" which is just tyranny of the ordinary sort.

For this end seems to be the only thread that hold his argument together. He begins by lamenting democracy, bemoaning that the principle of "one person, one vote" results in relatively less power in Statehouses for regions which are devoid of people. "It is not fair that our faction lost that election", they moan, "just because we had fewer votes!" 

And how does he propose to remedy this? By massively expanding the powers of Congress to micro-manage state governments - a de facto abolition of federalism. For, since it is the strictest laws that bind, saying that no law may be stricter than Federal law is akin to saying no law binds but federal law. Apparently, being governed by a representative statehouse you dislike is so intolerable that it would be better to give all power to Congress, which already massively over-represents rural people and their interests - a fact obvious to anyone with a passing familiarity with the Federal budget and its consistent and systematic transfers from urban areas to rural areas.

P.S.
I would just like to say how much I appreciate the work of USA Today, which I quite sincerely think is the finest newspaper in America, because it aims to speak the truth plainly to all Americans.